|








| |
Conducting
Forensic Evaluations on Suspected Abuse Cases
by
Frances S Waters, DCSW, LMFT, Copyright, 03/2001
Abusive
Family Pathology
 | Intergenerational history of abuse, neglect,
abandonment |
 | Mental illness |
 | Substance abuse |
 | Domestic violence |
 | Transient lifestyle |
 | Repeated reports of abuse, neglect,
abandonment of children |
 | Criminal history |
SYMPTOMS OF TRAUMATIZED CHILDREN
 | PTSD |
 | nightmares, |
 | reocurring thoughts/feelings |
 | Startled responses |
 | Hypervigilant |
 | Dissociation |
 | Trancing |
 | Amnesia |
 | Separate states |
 | Somatoform Dissociation-bodily complaints |
 | Somatoform Dissociation |
 | Somataform Dissociation: Phenomena,
Measurement & Theoretical Issues, Nijenhuis, E.R.S. 1999.
Early works of Briquet (1859), Charcot (1877), Janet (1893): |
 | multiple medically unexplained & often
chronic physical complaints |
 | Contemporary researchers: Ellenberger
(1970), Hilgard (1977), Van der Hart (1989), Van der Kolk & Van der Hart
(1989), Nijenhuis, (1990) |
 | Somatoform Dissociation: somato=body,
form=mind |
 | SDQ-20; SDQ-5 |
 | Promiscuity & other sexualized
problems |
 | Masturbation |
 | Sexually acting out with age mates |
 | Sexually perpetrating younger children,
siblings |
 | Conduct Problems & legal issues |
 | Fire setting |
 | Animal torture |
 | Aggression |
 | Preoccupation with guns, knives |
 | Shoplifting |
 | ADHD & learning problem |
 | Substance Abuse Problems |
 | Depression |
 | Anxiety |
 | Eating Disorders |
 | Obsessive Compulsive Disorders |
 | Borderline Personality Disorder |
 | Suicidal and self-destructive behaviors |
 | Picking sores |
 | Pulling hair out |
 | Cutting |
 | Overdose |
Traumatized Children & Protective Issues:
Challenges
 | Dealing with a hyper-aroused child, a
fearful child |
 | Questions set off alarm systems |
 | Be astute to child tuning out, not
listening, trancing out |
 | Understand that child’s memory, feelings,
thoughts, behavior related to the suspected abuse may be dissociated, and
not related to false allegation, intentional misinformation, etc. |
 | Understand that child’s memory may contain
degrees of amnesia, and information provided may have gaps, missing pieces |
 | Need to counteract suppression
techniques-threats, etc. |
 | Need to protect the child, but child may need to be in safe place to be
able to recall traumatic memories, improve memory, improve verbal &
cognitive skills |
 | Be aware that vulnerable young children may include fantasy rescue
scenarios as a way to defend against the feeling of being defenseless and
vulnerable at the time of trauma |
 | Deciphering between no abuse and dissociated traumatic memories through
careful observation, collection of data from referral source, and ongoing
collaboration with treatment team |
Traumatized Children & Protective Issues: Intervention Strategies
 | Protective service workers play a crucial role in the beginning process of
a child’s recovery. |
 | Be on PAR with the child! |

 | Interviewer Guidelines (State of Michigan Forensic Interviewing Protocol) |
 | Avoid wearing uniforms or having guns visible during the interview |
 | Convey & maintain a relaxed, friendly atmosphere |
 | Avoid touching the child |
 | Do not use bathroom breaks or drinks as reinforcement for cooperating
during the interview |
 | Respect the child’s personal space in positioning yourself to the
child, and staring at the child |
 | If child becomes upset, reassure child about feelings of fear, &
embarrassment |
 | Interviewer Guidelines |
 | Do not make promises, i.e., “Everything will be o.k.” “You will
never have to talk about this again.” |
 | Do not make comments such as “good girl,” or “we’re buddies,
aren’t we?” |
 | Do not use words “pretend,” “imagine,” or other words that may
suggest fantasy or play |
 | Avoid asking questions about why the child behaved in a particular way,
e.g., “Why didn’t you tell your mother that night?” |
 | Avoid correcting the child’s behavior unnecessarily during the
interview-redirect child’s attention with meaningful explanations, e.g.,
“I have a little trouble hearing, so it helps me a lot if you look at me
when you are talking so that I can hear you.” |
 | If you can’t understand what the child said, ask the child to repeat
the comment with phrases, e.g., “What did you say?” instead of
guessing. |
 | Be tolerate of pauses in conversation-time to formulate next question |
Traumatized Children & Protective
Issues: Phased Interview
 | Preparing the interview environment |
 | Room has minimal distractions |
 | Drawing paper & crayons |
 | Anatomical drawings & dolls |
 | The introduction |
 | Brief; explain role- “I am a social worker that talks to kids about
things that have happened to them.” |
 | Build a rapport |
 | Begin on a positive note-inquire about child’s age, school,
interests, who lives with the child |
 | Legal Competency |
 | Truth & lie question |
 | Establishing the Ground Rules |
 | Explain if child may not understand a question to say so |
 | Explain that the child can say, “I don’t know,” when applicable |
 | Completing Rapport Building with a Practice Interview |
 | Ask child about a recent event to elicit as much information about it. |
 | Use open-ended prompts, such as, “Tell me everything you can about that.” |
 | Invite child to be informative with comments such as, “Tell me
everything that happened, even little things you don’t think are very
important,” or “Tell me everything that happened, from the very
beginning to the very end.” |
 | Interviewer can encourage child to talk with head nods, “Ohhhh,”
partial repetitions of child’s last comment. |
 | Children who have little to say about specific events may be able to
describe a repeated, scripted event |
 | Every morning when getting ready for school |
 | Favorite restaurant |
 | Introducing the Topic |
 | Starts with the least suggestive prompts that might raise the topic of
abuse, avoiding mention of particular individuals or events |
 | “Now that I know you a little better, it’s time to talk about
something else. Do you know why you are here today?” |
 | “Now that we know each other a little better, I want to talk about the
reason that you are here today. Tell me the reason you came to talk with
me today.” |
 | “I understand someone has been bothering you |
 | The Free Narrative |
 | Encourage the child to describe the events in his or her own words by
using open-ended invitations such as, “Tell me everything you can about
that.” “Then what?” “Tell me more about that.” |
 | “I talk with a lot of children about these sorts of things. It’s
okay to tell me all about it, from the very beginning to the very end.” |
 | Be tolerant of pauses in the conversation |
 | If child becomes upset or non-responsive, acknowledge the child’s
behavior & address it, but avoid extensive comments about it. “Can
you tell me why you are crying.” |
 | Questioning and Clarification |
 | Use the least suggestive question
possible, working for a complete description of one event before shifting
to a different topic. |
 | Ask questions that would elicit sensory information, i.e. look, smell,
taste, etc. |
 | May have to ask questions in follow up contextual framework |
 | Happened in bedroom, kitchen, living room |
 | Frequency questions are difficult for a young child or a chronically
abused child |
 | Did it happen more than once? |
 | When asking the child to tell “everything,” be aware that delayed
disclosure & disclosure in stages can occur |
 | If child talks about “grandpa,” ask if grandpa has another name |
 | Young children may stray off topic & begin to discuss other events |
 | Clarify, e.g. “Are you talking about the time in the kitchen?” |
 | Complete information in one interview may not be possible |
 | Don’t assume that the child is being
untruthful, if you do not get all details, or some discrepancies |
 | Make reference that all parts of child’s
mind may know something about what happened |
 | Ask the child to go inside his mind to see
if he can remember what happened next, etc. |
 | Be aware of own biases toward material
reported (ritual abuse) |
 | Be aware of counter-transference
issues-own history of trauma |
 | Closure |
 | “Is there something else you’d like to
tell me about____?” |
 | “Are there any questions you would like
to ask me?” |
 | Thank the child for coming, but be careful
not to specifically thank the child for disclosing the abuse. |
 | Do not make promises can’t keep-no more
interviews about abuse |
 | Give your contact name & phone number
in case they think of something they want to add. |
Traumatized Children & Protective
Issues: Intervention Strategies
 | Protective Service Interventions |
 | Collaborate closely with the treating
therapist |
 | Develop a unified treatment plan to
protect the child |
 | Understand that new information may be
revealed at a latter date, and may require updated interviews, revised
treatment plans |
 | REFERRAL FOR MENTAL HEALTH ASSESSMENT
ASAP!!! |
 | Every child in placement has been
traumatized by the mere fact of placement, itself, regardless of how
necessary. |
 | Every child in placement has suffered some
degree of trauma as a result of some form of neglect, abuse, and/or
abandonment, which caused placement. |
 | Be astute to symptoms commonly seen in
traumatized children |
 | Safe & Protective Environment is
crucial to recover & benefit from treatment |
 | Early intervention to process traumatic
events is best form of prevention of future behavior and emotional
problems |
Children can reclaim their
lives with your help.
Be on PAR with the child!

|