SASPCAN

The South African Society for the Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect

 

Home
About Us
Contact Details
News & Events
Services
Newsletters
Links
Search

 

Conducting Forensic Evaluations on Suspected Abuse Cases by Frances S Waters, DCSW, LMFT, Copyright, 03/2001

Abusive Family Pathology

bulletIntergenerational history of abuse, neglect, abandonment
bulletMental illness
bulletSubstance abuse
bulletDomestic violence
bulletTransient lifestyle
bulletRepeated reports of abuse, neglect, abandonment of children
bulletCriminal history

SYMPTOMS OF TRAUMATIZED CHILDREN 

bulletPTSD
bulletnightmares,
bulletreocurring thoughts/feelings
bulletStartled responses
bulletHypervigilant
bulletDissociation
bulletTrancing
bulletAmnesia
bulletSeparate states
bulletSomatoform Dissociation-bodily complaints
bulletSomatoform Dissociation
bulletSomataform Dissociation: Phenomena, Measurement & Theoretical Issues, Nijenhuis, E.R.S. 1999.
Early works of Briquet (1859), Charcot (1877), Janet (1893):
bulletmultiple medically unexplained & often chronic physical complaints
bullet Contemporary researchers: Ellenberger (1970), Hilgard (1977), Van der Hart (1989), Van der Kolk & Van der Hart (1989), Nijenhuis, (1990)
bulletSomatoform Dissociation: somato=body, form=mind
bulletSDQ-20; SDQ-5
bulletPromiscuity & other sexualized problems 
bulletMasturbation
bulletSexually acting out with age mates 
bulletSexually perpetrating younger children, siblings 
bulletConduct Problems & legal issues
bullet Fire setting 
bulletAnimal torture 
bulletAggression 
bulletPreoccupation with guns, knives 
bulletShoplifting
bulletADHD & learning problem 
bulletSubstance Abuse Problems 
bulletDepression 
bulletAnxiety 
bulletEating Disorders 
bulletObsessive Compulsive Disorders
bulletBorderline Personality Disorder
bulletSuicidal and self-destructive behaviors
bulletPicking sores
bulletPulling hair out
bulletCutting
bulletOverdose

Traumatized Children & Protective Issues: Challenges

bulletDealing with a hyper-aroused child, a fearful child
bulletQuestions set off alarm systems
bulletBe astute to child tuning out, not listening, trancing out
bulletUnderstand that child’s memory, feelings, thoughts, behavior related to the suspected abuse may be dissociated, and not related to false allegation, intentional misinformation, etc.
bulletUnderstand that child’s memory may contain degrees of amnesia, and information provided may have gaps, missing pieces
bulletNeed to counteract suppression techniques-threats, etc.
bulletNeed to protect the child, but child may need to be in safe place to be able to recall traumatic memories, improve memory, improve verbal & cognitive skills
bulletBe aware that vulnerable young children may include fantasy rescue scenarios as a way to defend against the feeling of being defenseless and vulnerable at the time of trauma
bulletDeciphering between no abuse and dissociated traumatic memories through careful observation, collection of data from referral source, and ongoing collaboration with treatment team

Traumatized Children & Protective Issues:  Intervention Strategies

bulletProtective service workers play a crucial role in the beginning process of a child’s recovery.
bulletBe on PAR with the child!

bulletInterviewer Guidelines (State of Michigan Forensic Interviewing Protocol)
bulletAvoid wearing uniforms or having guns visible during the interview
bulletConvey & maintain a relaxed, friendly atmosphere
bulletAvoid touching the child
bulletDo not use bathroom breaks or drinks as reinforcement for cooperating during the interview
bulletRespect the child’s personal space in positioning yourself to the child, and staring at the child
bulletIf child becomes upset, reassure child about feelings of fear, & embarrassment
bulletInterviewer Guidelines
bulletDo not make promises, i.e., “Everything will be o.k.” “You will never have to talk about this again.”
bulletDo not make comments such as “good girl,” or “we’re buddies, aren’t we?”
bulletDo not use words “pretend,” “imagine,” or other words that may suggest fantasy or play
bulletAvoid asking questions about why the child behaved in a particular way, e.g., “Why didn’t you tell your mother that night?”
bulletAvoid correcting the child’s behavior unnecessarily during the interview-redirect child’s attention with meaningful explanations, e.g., “I have a little trouble hearing, so it helps me a lot if you look at me when you are talking so that I can hear you.”
bulletIf you can’t understand what the child said, ask the child to repeat the comment with phrases, e.g., “What did you say?” instead of guessing.
bulletBe tolerate of pauses in conversation-time to formulate next question

Traumatized Children & Protective Issues:  Phased Interview

bulletPreparing the interview environment
bulletRoom has minimal distractions
bulletDrawing paper & crayons
bulletAnatomical drawings & dolls
bulletThe introduction
bulletBrief; explain role- “I am a social worker that talks to kids about things that have happened to them.”
bulletBuild a rapport
bulletBegin on a positive note-inquire about child’s age, school, interests, who lives with the child
bulletLegal Competency
bulletTruth & lie question
bulletEstablishing the Ground Rules
bulletExplain if child may not understand a question to say so
bulletExplain that the child can say, “I don’t know,” when applicable
bulletCompleting Rapport Building with a Practice Interview
bulletAsk child about a recent event to elicit as much information about it.
bulletUse open-ended prompts, such as, “Tell me everything you can about that.”
bulletInvite child to be informative with comments such as, “Tell me everything that happened, even little things you don’t think are very important,” or “Tell me everything that happened, from the very beginning to the very end.”
bulletInterviewer can encourage child to talk with head nods, “Ohhhh,” partial repetitions of child’s last comment.
bulletChildren who have little to say about specific events may be able to describe a repeated, scripted event
bulletEvery morning when getting ready for school
bulletFavorite restaurant
bulletIntroducing the Topic
bulletStarts with the least suggestive prompts that might raise the topic of abuse, avoiding mention of particular individuals or events
bullet“Now that I know you a little better, it’s time to talk about something else. Do you know why you are here today?”
bullet“Now that we know each other a little better, I want to talk about the reason that you are here today. Tell me the reason you came to talk with me today.”
bullet“I understand someone has been bothering you
bulletThe Free Narrative
bulletEncourage the child to describe the events in his or her own words by using open-ended invitations such as, “Tell me everything you can about that.” “Then what?” “Tell me more about that.”
bullet“I talk with a lot of children about these sorts of things. It’s okay to tell me all about it, from the very beginning to the very end.”
bulletBe tolerant of pauses in the conversation
bulletIf child becomes upset or non-responsive, acknowledge the child’s behavior & address it, but avoid extensive comments about it. “Can you tell me why you are crying.”
bulletQuestioning and Clarification
bulletUse the least suggestive question possible, working for a complete description of one event before shifting to a different topic.
bulletAsk questions that would elicit sensory information, i.e. look, smell, taste, etc.
bulletMay have to ask questions in follow up contextual framework
bulletHappened in bedroom, kitchen, living room
bulletFrequency questions are difficult for a young child or a chronically abused child
bulletDid it happen more than once?
bulletWhen asking the child to tell “everything,” be aware that delayed disclosure & disclosure in stages can occur
bulletIf child talks about “grandpa,” ask if grandpa has another name
bulletYoung children may stray off topic & begin to discuss other events
bulletClarify, e.g. “Are you talking about the time in the kitchen?”
bulletComplete information in one interview may not be possible
bulletDon’t assume that the child is being untruthful, if you do not get all details, or some discrepancies
bulletMake reference that all parts of child’s mind may know something about what happened
bulletAsk the child to go inside his mind to see if he can remember what happened next, etc.
bulletBe aware of own biases toward material reported (ritual abuse)
bulletBe aware of counter-transference issues-own history of trauma
bulletClosure
bullet“Is there something else you’d like to tell me about____?”
bullet“Are there any questions you would like to ask me?”
bulletThank the child for coming, but be careful not to specifically thank the child for disclosing the abuse.
bulletDo not make promises can’t keep-no more interviews about abuse
bulletGive your contact name & phone number in case they think of something they want to add.

Traumatized Children & Protective Issues:  Intervention Strategies

bulletProtective Service Interventions
bulletCollaborate closely with the treating therapist
bulletDevelop a unified treatment plan to protect the child
bulletUnderstand that new information may be revealed at a latter date, and may require updated interviews, revised treatment plans
bulletREFERRAL FOR MENTAL HEALTH ASSESSMENT ASAP!!!
bulletEvery child in placement has been traumatized by the mere fact of placement, itself, regardless of how necessary.
bulletEvery child in placement has suffered some degree of trauma as a result of some form of neglect, abuse, and/or abandonment, which caused placement.
bulletBe astute to symptoms commonly seen in traumatized children
bulletSafe & Protective Environment is crucial to recover & benefit from treatment
bulletEarly intervention to process traumatic events is best form of prevention of future behavior and emotional problems

Children can reclaim their lives with your help.
Be on PAR with the child!

 

 

Copyright SASPCAN 1999 - 2003.  Last updated 19 August 2003 . 
For queries about SASPCAN please mail saspcan@absamail.co.za